
My Silver Kings friends have started something else. You’ll recall our Wednesday meetings began as a SAGA group, the Dark Ages skirmish game. I love it. I’ve built my four armies with three more ready to be painted. We’re scheduled to play SAGA the first and third Wednesdays of the month.
The alternate Wednesdays are open and we’ve tried a variety of different things. However the one game that has had staying power is The Middle Earth Strategy Battle Game system from Games Workshop. I know what you’re thinking-Games Workshop, yikes. But honestly, Games Workshop, Warlord Games, Gripping Beast/Studio Tomahawk; it’s all kinda corporate and I don’t care for it, but the games are fun and my friends like it, so I’m in.
I’ve played the game system three or four times. It’s a little fiddly and I haven’t quite picked it up perfectly, but I really do like it. There are three reasons I’ll share below.
Let me start with the first and most important. I am a lifelong Tolkien admirer. I read the Lord of the Rings for the first time when I was 13. 56 years later I’ve probably read the LoTR more than 25 times (I’m reading it now.) I’ve read many of the books associated with that story more than once (yes, including the Silmarillion several times.) I love the stories and the craft that went into assembling an alternate world with an alternate history. That I can play a game kinda based on my favorite piece of writing is wonderful.
Note* Yes it does irritate me that this game, and many current aspects of LoTR is based on Peter Jackson’s great movies rather than Tolkien’s even better books. The game is weird because it generally follows Jackson, though some characters not in the movie show up in the game.
Second, it may come as no surprise to you that I’ve squirreled away a bunch of GW Middle Earth figures. These were released with The Two Towers game box in 2004 and I couldn’t help myself. They lived in a couple of tubs under a record case until recently. GW miniatures are hideously expensive due to all that Tolkien Family licensing that must be paid. Due to the wonders of 3D printing, many Tolkienesque figures are available on the market (though not called by Tolkien names) at a somewhat more reasonable price. It may not surprise you that I have purchased far more of these than sense will allow. I’ve painted about half the figures I had stashed, and can hardly contain my enthusiasm for those soon to arrive.

Finally, I’ve always wanted to game the Lord of the Rings. I have three battles I’ve always wanted to game. They are Agincourt 1415, The Battle of Guilford Courthouse 1780, and The Battle of the Pelennor Fields from The Return of the King. I’ve followed DBA/DBM Middle Earth games. I’ve written my own set of rules for 15mm (and I have the figures to boot.) Honestly GW has done the best job of putting together a system and scenarios to do what I’d like to do with these rules and my figures. I’ve always identified mostly closely with the horse lords of Rohan who seem a bit like the Ostrogoths of the 5th century. Their super spendy supplement on the Wars of Rohan does a great job of tracing the story of the Rohirrim from the fall of the Westfold to Theoden’s charge at the Pelennor Fields.
The rules themselves are nicely made, full of color pictures and very expensive, like many sets of rules are. I find the rules mechanically not difficult, but with a fair number of steps for each combat. The rules, in the book, really aren’t very helpful. They ramble and are hard to follow in play. I can’t imagine what new gamers think. What they really need is a super QRS which the rules oddly don’t have. Lots of fan work to help support this game that is very welcome, but GW simply must do a better job. Of course, a revised edition is just around the corner, but I gave my 57 bucks at the office.

If I have a beef, it is one that is held by all lovers of Tolkien. The books, the figures, the scenarios are all based on Peter Jackson’s wonderful movies. The good side of that is that the movies were quite good, but they did take liberties with Tolkien’s story. It is not my interest to make a big giant list of those here. Some were understandable, some were really silly, and some made some profound changes to the story. What’s really weird is to see Games Worshop take the Peter Jackson route with most things while including some Peter Jackson omissions. Here are a couple of my favorites.
The Rohan commander Erkenbrand commanded the forces that were broken by Isengard and the Dunland wild men leading up to the battle of Helm’s Deep. He is completely ignored by Jackson, but an Erkenbrand hero is available in the GW story. In the movie it is Eomer who arrives to save the day at Helm’s Deep with lord knows how many mounted Rohirrim. In the Two Towers, Eomer is desperately fighting alongside his uncle at the Hornburg, and Erkenbrand arrives with Gandalf to rescue Theoden with a thousand infantry. GW gives an important Tolkien character an under-the-table acknowledgement, Jackson omitted.
Gamling is another character that appears askew in both the GW game and the Peter Jackson movie. Gamling appears as the doorwarden or captain of the Royal Guard of the King’s palace at Edoras in the movie. In the book this character is named Hama. Hama accompanies Theoden to Helm’s Deep where he is killed at the gate. Alas, no Hama in the movie, but his character is recognized in the rules. In the Two Towers Gamling is recognized as Gamling the Old. He is a venerable captain of the Westfold forces who retreat to the old castle and continues to gather his troops to man the walls as the King and his thousand horsemen ride in.
Okay, enough already. If the movies and the rules share some imperfections, okay, my real concern has always been that the Lord of the Rings will be forgotten as a great work of fiction, but be remembered as three really awesome movies. But, alas and alack, that will always be my concern. However, as a game, though I often look down my nose at Games Workshop, MESBG is pretty darn good and I’m happy to join in the fun.




































































